Skip to main content

Encounter: Bypassing The Third Pillar

Who would have thought that pictures of a model-like guy will be used to show an innocent who was murdered in one of Karachi’s encounter killings. While common sense treats him far from being involved in terrorist activities, the statements of friends and family members, and the overall image portrayed through social media depicts him as a broadminded gentleman.
The term encounter is used when policemen or other law enforcement officials retaliate in self-defence whenever they are attacked by suspected gangsters or terrorists. Pakistan’s constitution itself requires police to produce suspects before law, and accountability of those who carry out unlawful killings.
Muhammad Ali Nekokara, a former police officer, writes that encounter deaths are often justified by moral righteousness and passive obedience to authority. Nekokara noted that rogue elements within the police department benefit from these killings in terms of power and authority. This gives rise to the so-called ‘encounter specialists’ like Malir SSP Rao Anwar who maintain their monopoly within an area for unusually long periods.
Anwar has remained a controversial policeman. He had participated in the 1992 Karachi operation, and was transferred back to Karachi only when PPP came to power in 2007.  His rivals claim that he is feared in the outskirts of the metropolitan for taking hefty bribes, having stayed as the senior superintendent of the area for the last nine years – in violation of Police Order of 2002.
High ranking police officials opine that the phenomenon of extra-legal killings mushroom when criminal-minded policemen make their own ‘gangs’ to extort money from criminals by threatening to kill them by shootout, or when they are involved in settling personal vendetta.  For this reason, some Pakistani police officials are made to believe that encounter is “to make sure that no criminal escapes justice because of lack of evidence and witnesses”.
Staged encounters also occur because of gaps within the criminal justice system where complication in prosecution of criminals is caused due to lack of functional relationship between police, laws, prosecutors, lawyers and judges.
Encounter killings are not new in Pakistan – especially after threat of terrorism. They not only oppose the human rights but also compromise the whole system of justice – bypassing the third pillar of state.
In 2016, the Human Rights Watch had charged Pakistani police of fake encounters, torture and extrajudicial killings with over 2,000 people reportedly killed.  A report compiled by the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan (HRCP) calls impunity as one of the main factors causing extra-legal killings, asking the government to probe every encounter killing.
Targeted operations, whether in South Punjab or Karachi, may or may not result in lessening the serious crimes, though they result in killing several suspects in police encounters. These killings are likely to go unchecked since there is little investigation and no prosecution despite complaints received by the HRCP.
An active policy of awareness and reforms within the criminal justice system are long awaited. Incidents like that of Naqeeb Mehsud have brought to light the lack of eagerness of the police department to investigate the suspected extra-judicial killings.

By: Umair Sohail

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Karachi – the city where your ‘mochi’ can also mend your soul

The 42-year-old Khan took over his father’s mochi business after the latter retired four years ago. PHOTO: SARAH FAZLI Karachi is home to the most diverse of populations across Pakistan. Muslims, non-Muslims, Shia, Sunni, Muhajir, Balochi, Sindhi, Pashtun, Kashmiri, and also many other minority groups; many a people have found home here. Some of them love Karachi, others hate it. But Karachi has embraced them all – giving them the freedom to be themselves. Some folks weave dreams during the day. Some have adopted a nocturnal lifestyle and work during the night. Some read Jane Austen, while some unfalteringly quote  Faiz Ahmad Faiz . Some revere and find solace in its shrines. And yet, others destroy the very sanctity of those shrines. Some try to restore its glory, while others try to slaughter this goose to steal all its golden eggs. All of this happens at once, and this diversity is what makes Karachi both beautiful and painful. Vibrant and colourful, yet...
Post a Comment
Read more

Notification issued for composition of new administrative divisions in Mohmand, Khyber

Over a month after landmark legislation was passed to merge the tribal districts with the settled areas, the provincial government on Thursday officially notified the administrative divisions and districts in the merged areas. A notification issued by the Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa Board of Revenue on Thursday changed the geographic composition of Peshawar division by adding two tribal districts including Mohmand and Khyber, previously part of the Federally Administered Tribal Areas (Fata), along with the addition of the Frontier Region Peshawar. The Peshawar division now comprises five districts including Peshawar, Charsadda, Nowshera, Mohmand and Khyber. The notification further states that the administrative divisions have been altered in pursuant to 25th Amendment Act regarding the merger of the erstwhile Fata areas in the province and in the exercise of the powers conferred as per section 6, Chapter-II of Land Revenue Act 1967. NA passes ‘historic’ Fata, K-P merge...
Post a Comment
Read more

MS Dhoni – an era on his own

MS Dhoni of India hits out during the third Royal London One-Day International between England and India at Headingley on July 17, 2018 in Leeds, England. PHOTO: GETTY He came, he saw, he conquered. These words are the very least one can associate with Mahendra Singh Dhoni  for his performance thus far in international cricket. By placing the ball behind the square through to the third man boundary for a single, he recently achieved the milestone of making  10,000 ODI runs . On July 14, 2018 at Lord’s, the home of cricket, he became only the 12 th  batsman in the history of ODI cricket to achieve this rare feat. MS Dhoni plays a shot during the second ODI against England at Lords in London on July 14, 2018. Photo: Reuters As a fan, there are several memories I associate with the accomplishments of this gentleman. From his early days as a boy from a small town, the passage he passed through and the circumstances he overcame to get to this point, it all ...
Post a Comment
Read more